Touchstones: Kim Lane Scheppele


The bloodless transformation of our government into a harmful instrument of power is surreal. The people’s obligation to object to the executive’s abuse of his power is one we’ve never been called to on this scale. Normally, we rely on Congress to check the president through the power of impeachment and to assert its authority as a law-making body vis-a-vis the president, whose proper role is to execute and abide by Congress’s will. This isn’t happening. Instead, governmental institutions are being gutted and the president is forcefully intimidating universities, broadcasting companies, newspapers, and prominent individuals who together uphold our civil liberties, maintain civil society, and keep us informed.

Kim Scheppele is an American sociologist who studies authoritarian regimes and those who oppose them. She points out that Americans are relatively disadvantaged because they have never experienced authoritarianism before. They differ from the Poles, for example, whose history of subjugation over the centuries has served them well. When the independence of their judiciary was threatened in recent years, Poles immediately took to the streets and averted an erosion of the rule of law.

Our power to resist Donald Trump’s authoritarian tendencies will never be greater than it is right now. As Trump indulges his appetite for absolute power and makes a kleptocracy out of “the land of the brave,” will Americans sit by?

Please circulate this post to others and let me know what you think.

2 responses

  1. So many powerful and wise voices, but how do we pull it all together to stop the momentum? It’s a long time before the midterm elections.

    • The election of 2024 more or less gave away the keys of the kingdom to Trump and Trumpism. Everyone who wanted something other than his agenda is more or less powerless, and at the same time being cast into a situation that urgently requires opposition. The party system has let us down. So, there is an unprecedented need for citizens to unite in defense of civil liberties and the principle of self-government in an inclusive and non-partisan way. Limiting the harm involves: working to get a few more moderates in the legislatures, suing Trump like crazy, scaling up public demonstrations, and shaming those who are disgracing themselves and us by doing Trump’s will. I believe these measures can collectively make a difference in the nation’s trajectory. Republicans are under tremendous pressure already and this is only going to build as the folly of Trump’s trade “policy” begins to be felt.

      Regardless, action is the only way to avoid being complicit in wrong-doing. It’s a good in itself.

Discover more from American Inquiry

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading