American Inquiry

Quality Media From Chicago

Skip to content
  • Home
  • VIDEO
  • On Critical Elections
  • Contact
  • Index
  • About
  • Submissions

A Decision We’ll All Feel

28 Mar 2012 By Susan Barsy in Affordable Care Act Tags: Affordable Care Act, citizenship, health care, political engagement, protest, US Supreme Court, Washington DC 2 Comments

Today, for a third day, the Supreme Court will continue to hear arguments regarding the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act.  Crowds pack the courtroom; protesters swirl around outside; and those of us farther away are hearing same-day audio broadcasts of the proceedings, a rarity.  If nothing else, this event shows how knit together we’ve become as a nation.  As a capital, Washington DC used to be mocked as a place out of sight and far from the minds of the people; today it’s at the center of things, a nucleus of discourse and controversy.

The case is a landmark in another way.  There’s a lot of hype about it, and passions are keen on all sides.  Everyone understands something momentous is happening.  Unlike many Supreme Court decisions, which concern distinct subsets of people—union workers, say, or pregnant women, or juveniles in prison—, this one will affect all Americans directly.  Perhaps that’s what gives the proceedings a different feel.  Will we end up with a single integrated health-care system that acknowledges and includes us all, or will we continue with the old balkanized system that denies the fact that we are connected through it already?  Because, one way or another, we do already pay for the care that the uninsured need, and bear the indirect costs of their being ill, if you are inclined to monetize issues that way.

To strike down this complex and undoubtedly imperfect legislation would be undoing change that is happening already; more to the point, it would re-affirm Americans’ separatist tendencies: our determination to go it alone no matter what the costs or consequences.  On the other hand, should the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act be affirmed, we will find ourselves on a new road together, engaged in a massive and complex experiment whose likely outcomes are truly unknown.

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

Post navigation

« Up Salt River
Lay It on the Fire »

2 responses

  1. Pingback: Progress Isn’t Popular « Our Polity

  2. Pingback: The Next Political Football: Medicaid « Our Polity

WELCOME


American Inquiry publishes work on history, politics, photography, emotion, and threats to the human species.  It celebrates the promise of the American political tradition while presenting constructive ideas about the dangers facing the United States today.

CONTRIBUTORS GET PAID

American Inquiry invites you to publish something terrific with us this summer.  Visit the Submissions page for details.

SUBSCRIBE

It's free and private, and the only way to be sure of receiving every post.

the origins page has moved

Click here to view the pages on Slovakian Genealogy.

American Inquiry

Footer menu

  • Home
  • VIDEO
  • On Critical Elections
  • Contact
  • Index
  • About
  • Submissions
↑