1. I get embarrassed after expressing an opinion about Donald Trump, because I always feel that I don’t know what I am talking about. I am so burned out thinking about Donald Trump that sometimes I find myself having an anxiety attack at bedtime instead of drifting off to sleep, which just isn’t like me.
2. Sometimes I try to argue that Donald Trump can’t be such a terrible, dangerous person, because if he were, as a businessman, he would have already run into many, many problems with the law. Running a large company entails complying with innumerable laws. Workplace-safety laws. Food-safety laws. Laws governing equal employment. Building codes. Tax laws. Donald Trump must be a person of considerable ability and judgment, I reason, because he successfully built up such a big business. And because he likes to build things, I reason that he must be a constructive person by nature, who is not fundamentally interested in blowing up buildings and people in other countries. He must have had to deal with many different kinds of people successfully, at least well enough to get to ‘the handshake.’ Ultimately, keeping a massive corporation going depends on consistency and conformity; paradoxically it also depends on freshness and flexibility. Has Trump been a decent ‘river to his people’? Or has he been every bit as bad as Walmart, but just covered up his company’s misdeeds more adroitly? I reason to myself that if he had had major problems with the law and been a really bad ‘corporate citizen,’ his rivals would have outed him already, and the laundry list of his villainies would have made him a social pariah. (To me, the much-talked-about problems with Trump University just don’t count, for reasons made clear in item 6 below.)
3. I also feel embarrassed listening to Donald Trump because it weirdly resembles being privy to a private conversation. Sometimes, at press conferences or when addressing late-night crowds after a victory, Trump’s tone is oddly personal and conversational, as though nothing in particular were happening, and as though he were shooting the breeze with me over milk and cookies at the kitchen table. He gets a dreamy tone in his voice, talking about his employees, his hotels, his ‘operations,’ or the beautiful people of some state that’s just fallen to him. When he talks about Florida, for example, he relates it to his own history and enterprises, not the other way around. Sometimes it’s as though we are all going to be sucked up into the aura of Donald J Trump’s beautiful empire of luxury, leaving behind the angst and grunge of these second-rate United States. Will the golden touch of Donald Trump brush off on the likes of you and me? This is one fantastic effect of Donald Trump speaking.
4. But I also feel uncomfortable when Donald Trump is being ‘tough,’ when he is being ‘scandalous,’ because I’m never certain whether he’s being scandalous mainly because scandal sells. I know I should conclude that Donald Trump is ‘dangerous’ when friends say he is, but the way Donald Trump says many things, I find it difficult to nail his tone, to conclude that he is authentically mean and hateful. Is Donald Trump a very genial and glitzy version of a Nazi, or is he someone who uses shocking utterances to get people thinking about how the American reluctance to draw bounds around itself might have trade-offs when it comes to internal order and economic well-being? He is nearly alone in declaring loudly and in many registers that globalism has a big downside for the US, a downside that millions of citizens keenly feel. If Donald Trump were anything like Hitler, could the Clintons ever have been induced to attend his wedding? And what, then, to make of his rather noble tribute to Planned Parenthood, a compassionate tribute the likes of which have not been uttered by a leading Republican for decades?
5. What I know is that Donald Trump cares nothing about civility, a traditional standard governing political intercourse and acceptable public-sphere behavior. What does it matter if a person running for president has never held a public office? It means he or she has never had to practice being civil. Civility is the quality that keeps antagonistic parties on speaking terms, and what does effective government depend on more? Trump at a campaign rally, however, speaks as though in the privacy of a corporate sanctum. “Get them out” is a public-sphere translation of the message, “You’re fired!”, but firing a citizen is something not even the Donald can do. To me, the violence and hostility Trump’s speech, and his deliberate decision not to practice civility, indicate why, if elected, he might be a failure at governing.
6. Why do none of our objections matter? Nothing is gonna stick to Trump because he’s a charismatic leader. More than a century ago, the German sociologist Max Weber came up with the idea of ‘charismatic authority’ to explain why, seemingly in defiance of reason, some individuals inspire a large and faithful following. Weber noticed that the charismatic rise simply because their followers see exceptional qualities in them. Followers repose trust in such individuals on the basis of personality, not reason. A charismatic leader’s claims to power rest on the possession of “exceptional personal qualities or the demonstration of extraordinary insight and accomplishment,” which inspire loyalty and obedience. This relationship of trust helps explain why many Trump supporters have not wavered since deciding to back Trump at the beginning of his campaign. Whether his charismatic spell over voters will wane, or whether it can be converted into an effective mode of governance, remains to be seen.
7. Repeat the phrase, ‘Checks and balances,’ whenever the thought of President Trump induces panic. If he’s really awful, Congress will rebel and impeach his ass.
This was so interesting to read. I keep wondering if Donald Trump is for real too. I don’t believe he really feels anything in common with the masses of dumb, unwashed losers who are voting for him. For some reason it’s very important to him to be president.
Everything about him, his hair, his wives, his houses, reeks of otherness. He could be an alien from another planet. Trump is mysterious because he used to support things he now says he opposes. Is he pretending?
The reason he is dangerous is because he has chosen a group of very poor, marginalized people, Mexicans, to single out for abuse and hatred. They don’t deserve it, they can’t protect themselves and are not one of this country’s pressing problems. It is very, very ugly. I hope he isn’t elected.
One thing I’m looking forward to is a contested convention, if it comes to that, and the breaking apart of the GOP. I worry about what will replace it though. Let’s hope it’s not the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
Thank you for writing in, and so eloquently.
Yes, what is Trump’s motive? A friend believes it’s to promote his business. Trump himself has alluded to the singular thrill of political celebrity. What will he do when he’s in office, when the adulation dies down, and he’s constantly criticized for what he’s doing? His callous fomenting of hostility has broken the decorum that has characterized mainstream politics for decades. I agree that the GOP is likely to come asunder because of him, if not immediately, then in the next few years.
Good to hear from you.