American Inquiry

Quality Media From Chicago

Skip to content
  • Home
  • On Critical Elections
  • VIDEO
  • Submissions
  • THE WRITERS’ FUND
  • Index

Tag Archives: George Caleb Bingham

The Untouched and the Untouchables: Connecting to the Body Politic Today

4 Jul 2012 By Susan Barsy in Candidates and Campaigns Tags: 2012 election, apathy, campaigning, citizenship, efficiency ideal, George Caleb Bingham, networks, political customs, political engagement, political parties, social media, voting 6 Comments

George Caleb Bingham, "The Verdict of the People," St Louis Art Museum, courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

I FIGURED JUNE was a good time to go on a trip because, honestly, my practical role in politics is over until November.  Like many millions of Americans who are political, I grapple daily with the fact that as a citizen I am increasingly unnecessary.  No matter what my wishes, I must admit that, with the primary election in my state long over, there’s little left for me to do.

This is partly because I live in “a captive state” (and in a heavily Democratic city) that, come November, can be counted on to go a certain way.  If I want to see a negative campaign ad or some old-time campaign-trail mud-slinging, I’ve got to visit Unedited Politics (a fine online repository of contemporary political video, by the way).  It’s sad when watching second-hand commercials is what political involvement comes down to.

Don’t get me wrong: I always volunteer for candidates and give money, too.  My husband and I purchase gobs of campaign buttons to give away, because this basic currency of political attachment no longer circulates as freely as it used to.

Voters still want to be involved as much as ever, but campaigning—which once depended on face-to-face social relationships—has become much more impersonal and scientific.  Yes, we still rely on social networks to some extent, but this reliance is increasingly mediated by the commercial and technological tools campaigns love to use.  Campaigns no longer build social relationships—they just want to use mine.

This, and the fact that only a human can “pull the lever” in a voting booth, are the only things saving me from political extinction.

Otherwise, ordinary citizens are problematic in a political system where cash procures and arranges everything else.  Money comes into political coffers from the checkbooks of large entities and individuals; it goes out to consultants, mass-mailing experts, ad agencies, staffers, and media companies.  It all gets spent trying to connect the untouched and the untouchables: apathetic voters and their potential leaders.

This heavily capitalized and bureaucratic system overlays original democratic rituals that are still practiced, but with greater care, today: stumping, pressing the flesh, baby-kissing, even treating.  The messy, ribald rituals immortalized in works like George Caleb Bingham’s 1852 painting The County Election (below) would horrify us today, but the personal and social pleasures once part of politics were exactly what used to keep voters engaged.

George Caleb Bingham, "The County Election," St Louis Art Museum (courtesy of Wikimedia Commons).

Besides the déclassé (and male-dominated) nature of this scene, it is striking for its openness and  communality.  Candidates today are too worried about inefficiency and terrorism to contemplate taking part in anything so ordinary.  Ironically, the very success of our political model is killing off participatory democracy.  The last time I volunteered to work on a presidential campaign, I was encouraged to use the Internet and work remotely from home—an efficient arrangement that connected everyone but me.

Voters clamor for greater “say,” but power moves farther up the ladder, anyway.  As entire freeways close for the safe passage of official motorcades, and staffers orchestrate campaigns from within closed compounds, the disconnect in our body politic is likely to continue.

Images: George Caleb Bingham’s The Verdict of the People (1854-55, top)
and
The County Election (1852, bottom),
both owned by the St. Louis Art Museum, from this source and this.

RELATED:
Susan Barsy, The Closed-Door Campaign, Our Polity.
Susan Barsy, Political Affections, Our Polity.
Sasha Issenberg, Abolish the Secret Ballot, The Atlantic Monthly.
Walter Kirn, Knowledge of the Future is Messing with the Present, The Altantic Monthly.

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Post navigation

CURRENTS

12.14.2022  The stock market lost 2% of its value today, after data came out showing that November retail sales slowed more than foreseen.  The Dow closed down 711 points, after being down 950 earlier in the day.

12.6.2022  Raphael Warnock wins the Georgia runoff, defeating Hershel Walker in a suspenseful but blissfully decorous way.

12.5.2022  Some time ago, my accountant advised me to resolve the question of whether American Inquiry is being run as a hobby (in which case it really should be abandoned) or a business.  Despite knowing the difficulties of turning a profit from a publishing venture as small as this, I successfully petitioned the IRS earlier this year to reclassify American Inquiry as an S corporation, putting it on a conventional for-profit footing.  I have written a business plan for the website which envisions for generating revenue by various means, including an online bazaar and very low-cost classified advertising.  As I go about building these features into the site, American Inquiry may look unusually bare or ugly at times, and, for that, I humbly apologize.  I hope that the changes will lead to new kinds of engagement on the site, thus making the inconvenience of transitioning worthwhile.

Among the most consequential changes I have made: American Inquiry will no longer have followers.  New content will no longer be emailed to you.  I may later offer a paid subscription option, but until then I invite you to navigate to the website at your convenience for the newest content.  I am sincerely grateful for the readership of my followers in the past, and I hope it will continue in the new era.  Susan Barsy

SEE YOU NEXT TIME

SUSAN BARSY

the origins page has moved

Click here to view the pages on Slovakian Genealogy.

American Inquiry

Footer menu

  • Home
  • On Critical Elections
  • VIDEO
  • Submissions
  • THE WRITERS’ FUND
  • Index
↑
 

Loading Comments...